Tuesday 19 March 2013

Could Do Better


I spoke on the most recent episode of my podcast about the recent collapse of HMV and other high street retailers. I didn't really speak at length about it because I figure my podcast is more for jokes rather than for me dissecting the problems faced by the British economy. But that’s the nice thing about having a blog, if you don’t want to read about the economy you could just skip this post. Don’t though because I assure you that it’s going to be well interesting.

See also: every shop in Britain
The media narrative of the collapse of HMV, Jessops, Game, et al. (and indeed the narrative coming from those companies themselves) is that they have been crippled by the growth of online retailing and by rising rents on their stores. According to this view falling sales and rising costs were squeezing their profits. This view is easy to understand, which is probably why it is being pedalled. It is also false. HMV stores were all cash profitable, that is to say they were taking in more cash than they were spending because there are a lot of people (myself included) who still prefer to buy things in shops than over the internet. So why have they actually gone bust?